Fisher Island, Florida Housing Market Prices

Updated

Fisher Island Home Prices and Rent at a Glance

The median home price (often called the average home price), rent costs, affordability metrics, and housing stock characteristics for this housing market.

  • Median home price 318% above the Florida median
    $1,299,999
  • Median rent 17% below the Florida median
    $1,384

Housing Market Overview

Metric Fisher Island Florida Avg US Average
Median Home Price $1,299,999 $311,338 $248,835
Price Trend (Annual %) -1.0% 11.2% 7.5%
Median Gross Rent $1,384 $1,668 $1,407
Rent Trend (Annual %) 12.9% 6.2% 5.1%
Household Income Trend (Annual %) — — —

The median home price in Fisher Island is about 318% higher than in Florida. Rent is about 17% lower than the Florida average.

Median Home and Rent Price Trends

Median Home Prices, 2023-2024

Fisher Island
Florida
United States
Year Fisher Island Florida United States

Median Rent Prices, 2015-2024

Fisher Island
Florida
United States
Year Fisher Island Florida United States

Home prices and rent are moving in opposite directions in Fisher Island: home prices fell about 1.0% a year while rent rose about 12.9% a year. That is an unusual pattern worth watching.

Median rent in Fisher Island rose about 58.8% between 2015 and 2024, from $871 to $1,384. Over the same span, rent in Florida rose about 66.5%.

Affordability

On average, housing unit costs 13.7 yearly household incomes in Fisher Island.

Buying the median-priced home in Fisher Island costs roughly 78.3 years of rent at the median monthly rate. That is a relatively high price-to-rent ratio, which tends to favor renting over buying in Fisher Island. The price-to-rent ratio in Florida is about 15.6.

Metric Fisher Island Florida Avg US Average
Median Home Price $1,299,999 $311,338 $248,835
Median Household Income $95,075 $74,580 $80,455
Price-to-Income Ratio 13.7 4.2 3.1

Home Prices vs Income Over Time

Home Prices
Household Income

Between 2023 and 2024, the median home price in Fisher Island fell about 1.0%, while median household income rose about 6.2% between 2009 and 2025 — income grew faster than the home price.

Income Growth vs Housing Cost Growth (Year-over-Year %)

Compare income and housing cost trends.

Household Income Growth %
Housing Cost Growth %
Year Income Growth % Housing Cost Growth % Gap (Cost - Income)

Occupancy & Tenure

Metric Fisher Island Florida Avg US Average
Homeownership Rate 21.6% 57.7% 58.5%
Rental Rate 26.2% 27.7% 31.2%
Vacancy Rate 52.2% 14.6% 10.2%
Median Tenure (years) 17.0 13.0 15.0
Median Year Moved In 2009 2013 2011

Fisher Island has a homeownership rate of 21.6%, lower than the Florida average of 57.7%. Its housing vacancy rate is 52.2%, compared with 14.6% in Florida.

Housing Stock

Metric Fisher Island Florida Avg US Average
Average Household Size 1.82 people 2.50 people 2.53 people
Median Structure Built Year 1987 1988 1978
Median Number of Rooms 3.7 5.2 5.5

The typical housing unit in Fisher Island was built around 1987. On average, 1.8 people live in a home with about 3.7 rooms, staying for about 17.0 years on average.

Fisher Island, FL Housing Compared With Nearby Cities

How Fisher Island, FL compares with the 2 cities closest to it.

Area Population Median home price Median rent Homeownership
Fisher Island, FL 659 $1,299,999 #1/3 $1,384 #3/3 45.3% #1/3
Miami Beach, FL 64,801 $440,149 $1,835 41.7%
Miami, FL 456,657 $696,382 $1,761 31.0%

Frequently Asked Questions

Common questions about the housing market in Fisher Island, Florida.

What is the median home price in Fisher Island, Florida?

The median home price in Fisher Island, Florida is $1,299,999, higher than the Florida average of $311,338.

What is the average home price in Fisher Island, Florida?

The typical home price in Fisher Island, Florida, reported as the median sale price, is $1,299,999. The median is used instead of a mathematical average because it is not skewed by a small number of very expensive or very cheap homes, so it better reflects what a typical buyer pays.

What is the median rent in Fisher Island, Florida?

The median gross rent in Fisher Island, Florida is $1,384 per month, lower than the Florida average of $1,668.

What was the median gross rent in Fisher Island in 2020?

In 2020, the median gross rent in Fisher Island, Florida was $1,063 per month.

What is the price-to-rent ratio in Fisher Island, Florida?

The price-to-rent ratio in Fisher Island, Florida is about 78.3, meaning it would take roughly 78.3 years of rent payments at the median rent to equal the median home price. That is a relatively high price-to-rent ratio, which tends to favor renting over buying in Fisher Island.

Are home prices or rent rising faster in Fisher Island, Florida?

Home prices and rent are moving in opposite directions in Fisher Island: home prices fell about 1.0% a year while rent rose about 12.9% a year. That is an unusual pattern worth watching.

What is the homeownership rate in Fisher Island, Florida?

21.6% of households in Fisher Island, Florida own their home, lower than the Florida average of 57.7%.

What is the vacancy rate in Fisher Island, Florida?

The housing vacancy rate in Fisher Island, Florida is 52.2%, higher than the Florida average of 14.6%.

Size up the neighborhood around one home

Home values, rent, homeownership, schools, crime, health and nearby amenities for any US address, in one neighborhood report. Ready in about 3 minutes, in your browser or as a PDF.

Explore My Address →